Lack of Guidelines for the Principle of Good Law for its Application
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7499439Keywords:
Indirect Amparo, Appearance of Good Law, Amparo Trial, Suspension of the Claimed Act, Judge, Lawsuit, Legal CertaintyAbstract
With the present investigation it is analyzed that the principle of the appearance of good law turns out to be a negative element for the federal judge in matters of amparo, making the complainant believe that the law is in good standing, and the authorities use a bad right, which causes ambiguity, little legal certainty, and that the process in the amparo trial simulates a partiality, in the same way that legal institutions have resorted to this principle to satisfy a social grudge in the matter of suspension of the claimed act , when the purpose of said principle is an in-depth analysis of the case raised in light of the arguments made by the parties. Likewise, it will be demonstrated that the elements contained in the amparo law to grant provisional or outright suspension are sufficient to guide the judge, because they mark a legal guideline to be followed by the jurisdictional body, and that the principle of the appearance of good Right to lack guidelines for its application causes impartiality and that the judge in the matter of amparo, is subjected to a problem of ideologies, where the right can not be allowed to have.
Metrics
References
Arellano Garcia, Carlos. (2014). El juicio de Amparo. Distrito Federal: Porrua.
Chávez Castillo, Raúl. (2011). Ley de Amparo comentada. Distrito Federal: Porrúa.
Colegio de profesores de derecho civil-UNAM. (2016). Homenaje al Doctor Jorge Alfredo Dominguez Martínez . México: UNAM
Constitución Política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos. (2018). México: TIRANT LO BLANCH.
De Alba De Alba, Manuel. (2012). La apariencia del buen derecho en serio. México: Porrúa.
García de Enterría, Eduardo. (1995) La Batalla por las medidas cautelares. Madrid:Civitas.
Ley de amparo. (2018). Distrito Federal: ISEF.
Manríquez García, Carlos. La apariencia del buen derecho en el juicio de amparo
mexicano. Recuperado de: https://www.ijf.cjf.gob.mx/publicaciones/revista/10/10_7.pdf, fecha de consulta 18 de marzo del 2019
Pela Oviedo, Victor (2015). Ley de Amparo Comentada. Distrito Federal: Flores.
Suprema Corte de Justicia de la Nación. (2000). Manual del Juicio de Amparo. Distrito Federal: THEMIS.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
This journal adheres to the Creative Commons license in the definition of its policy of open access and reuse of published material, in the following terms:
- Accessibility to articles and other publications in whole or in part under the concept of copying, distribution, public communication , interactive access (through the Internet or other means), explicitly maintaining the recognition of the author or authors and the journal itself (authorship acknowledgment).
- Warning that if the articles are remixed, modified or fragments used in other creations, the modified material cannot be distributed, nor is it allowed to reconstruct versions from the original published articles (derived works).
- The use of the contents of the published articles, in whole or in part, for profit (non-commercial recognition) is prohibited.
The author retains copyright, transfers or grants exclusive commercial rights to the publisher, and a non-commercial license is used.
